It�s not easy
being an inshore angler in Northeast Florida during winter, especially
if you want to keep fish for the table. Once water temps drop below
60 degrees, fish tend to get sluggish. You can find flounder in the
back creeks, but they often run on the small side. Reds will be with
them, but you only get to take one of them home. Spotted seatrout are
a better option if a fish dinner is in the cards, but when the February
season closure rolls around, they are off the table, so to speak.
That�s why local
inshore experts welcome the winter run of yellowmouth trout.
"Yellowmouths
can save a lot of days during the winter," says Capt. Dennis Goldstein,
a 25-year veteran guide at Camachee Island Sport Fishing Charters in
St. Augustine. "Cold water doesn�t bother them at all and they�ll
feed aggressively in water temps in the low 50s. Pound for pound they�ll
definitely outfight a speckled trout, and are just as good on the table.
They�re also not included in the February trout closure, so you can
keep some�which makes these snowbird trout a pretty neat deal in my
book."
What local anglers
refer to as "yellowmouths" are more correctly known as weakfish,
although northern trout and gray trout are common nicknames. A member
of the Cynoscion family (which includes spotted trout, sand
trout and silver trout) their body shape is similar to the spotted trout,
although a bit more muscular. They also lack the distinct spots and
feature a more muted black dot pattern, with a more pronounced yellow
tinge to the inner mouth. Size-wise, the two species aren�t that far
apart and not more than two pounds separates the current IGFA world
records for both fish.
Don�t count
on catching a new world record weakfish in Florida, however. Much like
the Atlantic-strain striped bass, their primary range is in the Middle
Atlantic states, with the Florida Atlantic coast being on the extreme
southern edge of their range during cooler weather migrations. No weakfish
has ever been documented in the Gulf of Mexico.
The prime areas
in Florida stretch from Mayport to Matanzas, although some fish will
venture as far south as Fort Pierce, with Port Canaveral being about
the southernmost consistent producer. Being on the extreme edge of their
natural range, the fish we get run smaller, and the current Florida
limit is four fish with a minimum 12-inch size limit and no maximum
size restrictions. Experienced anglers aren�t quick to keep those
12-inch fish�two- to 4-pound fish are not uncommon and fish in the
5- to 8-pound class show up each year.
Just when they
show up depends on the weather and the locale, which can vary a bit.
"I�ll normally
start to target yellowmouths in mid-to-late November," says Capt.
John B. Snorkel, who guides out of Jacksonville Beach and works the
lower St. Johns River regularly. "From there they will generally hang
around until late February, although you can pick up a straggler or
two in early March."
To the south,
in St. Augustine, Dennis Goldstein waits until almost Christmas before
he begins to confidently include yellowmouths in his daily trips. From
there, he expects to reliably find those fish until mid-to-late March.
Anglers farther
south along the Atlantic coast will see a similar difference in when
these fish show up. What they won�t see, however, is any significant
difference in where the yellowmouths wind up. Although weakfish are
similar to spotted seatrout, and will sometimes be found with them,
their preferred habitat is quite a bit different from where the majority
of the spotted trout reside.
"Mature weakfish
are mostly a shelf animal," says Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation
Commission biologist Mike Murphy. "They prefer deeper waters and will
typically inhabit nearshore waters within a couple of miles of the coast.
They move inside inlets and estuaries during cold weather, but as a
general rule they don�t move very far inside."
You�ll get no
argument with that from guides. In the Mayport area, Capt. Snorkel finds
some of his best fish on the outside of the south side of the Mayport
jetties along the rocks in 20 to 25 feet of water, and on nearshore
structures (like the Mistake Barge and various rockpiles) located within
a couple of miles of the beach. In St. Augustine, Goldstein�s preferred
spots are the rocks on the south side of the St. Augustine Inlet in
25 to 30 feet of water and the nearshore wrecks, like Four Mile.
One obvious drawback
to those locales is winter weather. Scooting even a mile or two offshore
in a small boat is not always wise, and even a modest wind from any
easterly direction can make the jetties a tough place to fish. Fortunately,
enough yellowmouths venture inside the inlets to take the bite out of
all but the worst winter will offer.
In the St. Johns,
they routinely move upriver as far as Blount Island, and down the Intracoastal
Waterway to the Atlantic Blvd Bridge. In the St. Augustine/Matanzas
area they�ll roam even farther inside, and can be found southward
in the ICW from St. Augustine to Matanzas and as far north as Shell
Bluff, above Guana. That�s a pretty big area, but it�s not hard
to narrow the prime spots down�just look for them in spots where you
wouldn�t normally be looking for spotted trout.
"During winter,"
says Capt. Goldstein, "we catch a lot of speckled trout way up in
the shallow back creeks, and along some of the shallower drops in the
ICW. But, you won�t find any yellowmouths there. These fish want deeper
water, and there is not much point fishing for them shallower than 10
feet. I�m looking for 12 to 30 feet of water. Yellowmouths also want
a hard bottom. They are more structure-oriented than specks, and they
want a bottom with shell, rock or oyster, with some hard sand in the
immediate area.
"Bridges are
normally great spots," he continues, "and the 312 bridge is one
of the better ones. What we call the �Flounder Hole� by the jetties
at the entrance to Salt Run is good, and the deep hole by the old lighthouse
rock in Salt Run itself will hold them. Some of the creeks located close
to the jetties will have a deep hole at the mouth, with oyster, and
they are also reliable spots, but moving up any creek past the first
deep hole is generally a waste of time. You can find specks up there,
but darned few yellowmouths."
If you�re working
the right deep water, you may run into specks or yellowmouths, or a
combination of both. When Capt. Snorkel is hunting yellowmouths, the
ratio between the two�and their size�dictates whether he stays or
hits another spot.
"When you get
into yellowmouths, you might catch a speck or two," he says, "but
90 percent of the fish will be yellowmouths. If you�re catching mostly
specks, you�re not on a good yellowmouth bite. I�ve also found that
the fish inside the inlets generally school up by size. If the first
couple of yellowmouths I catch are in the 13-inch range I can figure
that they�re all going to be in the 12- to 14-inch range and I might
want to move on. If they�re 16-inch fish, then I�m looking at a
school in the 15- to 18-inch range and that�s not a bad place to stay
with. If I stick some 4- and 5-pound fish I�m not leaving."
Getting on a good
school of yellowmouths may take a little effort, but catching them doesn�t.
Just get your bait or lure within two feet of the bottom, and drift
it through the area not much faster than the current flow. These fish
feed well even when water temps are in the low 50s, and there is no
mistaking when they "thunk" a bait. Strikes are aggressive, but
the fish will stay deep.
When it comes
to effective offerings, there are a number of choices.
Yellowmouths will
hit lures if you can get them down to them. Plastic-bodied or bucktail
jigs in bright colors (red/yellow, chartreuse, red/white) are a good
choice. Sinking plugs like the MirrOlure 52M or Rat-L-Trap (chromes
with black or chartreuse) are also effective. All will be much more
effective if they are tipped with a small piece of shrimp, or one of
the newer synthetic baits like Fishbites or Berkley Gulp! These fish
like meat, and scent is always an asset in cold water.
Shrimp (either
live or fresh dead) is also an excellent choice, although its longevity
is limited around pinfish and snapper blues�both of which are likely
to be present when you find yellowmouths. Mud minnows and finger mullet
are more durable, and yellowmouths love them. These can be fished on
a hook and sinker rig, but it�s a lot easier and just as effective
to stick them on a bare jighead.
Don�t overlook
a strip, or chunk, of cutbait because yellowmouths relish these as well.
But, you may need a law degree to determine which species are legal
to use. The best opinion I have been able to get so far is that any
species subject to a size and possession limit (while perfectly legal
to use as bait in a whole condition) cannot be whittled into chunks
and strips since that runs afoul of the regulation prohibiting the "cleaning"
of "gamefish" while on the water.
As effective as
bait is (and yellowmouths do truly love meat!) the fluctuating availability
of shrimp, mud minnows and finger mullet during the winter months can
present problems for many anglers, and the complex rules on cutbait
are too complex for me. As a result, I don�t mess with any of it.
When yellowmouths
are the target I rig three rods with a bare wide-gapped jighead in 1/4-,
3/8- and 1/2-ounce. Regardless of the depth or current speed, one
of them will get me to the bottom at the proper drift speed. On the
back of each jighead goes an inshore formula shrimp-flavored Fishbites
strip. A chartreuse strip on a red jighead, or a pink strip on a chartreuse
head, gives me some eye-catching color and the Fishbites provides the
"meat" and scent. They work as well as shrimp (not only for yellowmouths,
but also specks, reds, flounder and anything else), are a lot more convenient,
and the pins and blues can�t strip them off the hook.
It�s a simple
approach�just get an effective bait to the fish. But, that�s what�s
cool about yellowmouths. They�re a simple fish. And, one that Northeast
Florida anglers are becoming quite fond of.
After all, what�s
not to like about a fish that shows up regularly, hangs out in easily
definable areas, hits eagerly in the coldest water, and is no slouch
on the table? This is one snowbird that is definitely welcome.